Initial Costs Versus Life-Cycle Costs

Maryam Mirhadi, Ph.D., VMA

Amin Terouhid, Ph.D., CVS

 

Executive takeaway. The alternative with the lowest initial costs does not necessarily provide the lowest total cost or the best value. A sound value engineering (VE) comparison first confirms that each alternative performs the required functions at an acceptable level. It then evaluates the resources each alternative will consume over an appropriate period. Life-cycle cost analysis places costs occurring at different times on a common economic basis so owners can reasonably compare alternatives.

Begin with function and performance

VE is a structured process for improving value by analyzing required functions and developing alternatives. SAVE International’s Value Methodology places function, or the main purposes that a system aims to serve, at the center of the analysis. [1]

Initial costs are the cost required to design, purchase, install, test, or place an alternative into service, whereas life-cycle cost (LCC) is the total cost of acquiring, operating, maintaining, replacing, and disposing of an asset over a defined period. A future dollar is not economically equivalent to a dollar spent today. Therefore, life-cycle cost analysis (LCCA) can be used as an economic method to calculate and compare those costs. Before performing LCCA, the team should confirm functional equivalence, that the alternatives provide the same required functions or at an enhanced level, and satisfy the owner’s minimum performance criteria.

Test the assumptions, not only the arithmetic

An LCC result is only as reliable as its inputs. Owners should document the source, timing, and uncertainty of each cost. Energy prices, operating hours, maintenance labor, component life, replacement scope, loss of service, and price escalation may change the ranking. As such, sensitivity analysis can be used to perform the systematic testing of how results change when uncertain inputs vary. By varying service life, energy cost, or the discount rate, the team can identify the conditions under which the preferred alternative changes.

It is important to note, however, that not every important factor can be priced reliably. Nonmonetized effects can still be evaluated without assigning a dollar value. Examples may include factors such as reliability, occupant comfort, operational continuity, safety, adaptability, environmental performance, and stakeholder impacts. These effects should be documented and evaluated alongside LCC. A lower LCC is not a sound recommendation if the alternative impairs a required function or creates unacceptable performance risk.

Recommendations for owners

As a professional recommendation, owners should confirm functional equivalence and minimum performance; define a common analysis period, base date, and cost basis; and include all relevant costs including acquisition, operation, maintenance, replacement, loss-of-service, and disposal costs. They also need to use current owner-approved economic assumptions; document data sources and uncertainty; test influential variables; and report initial costs, LCC, and nonmonetized effects separately to ensure a reasonable LCCA can be performed for reasonably assessing and comparing alternatives. This approach makes the reasoning transparent and keeps VE focused on the life cycle costs, not initial costs of alternatives.

References

[1] SAVE International. About the Value Methodology.

[2] Federal Highway Administration. Life-Cycle Cost Analysis.

Preparing for a Value Engineering Workshop

Amin Terouhid, Ph.D., CVS

Maryam Mirhadi, Ph.D., VMA

 

Executive takeaway. A productive value engineering (VE) workshop begins well before the team meets. The owner should define the decisions to be addressed, assemble reliable project information, involve team members or specialists who understand the project’s functions and constraints, and establish how recommendations will be reviewed. Effective preparation provides enough information for analysis while preserving enough flexibility to act on the results.

Define the assignment before assembling the team

Value engineering is a structured, multidisciplinary process for improving value by analyzing required functions and developing alternatives. SAVE International describes the Value Methodology as a systematic process that combines function analysis with creative problem-solving to improve value. [1]

A VE study is the complete analysis and reporting effort; the workshop is the facilitated working session in which the team applies the VE Job Plan. Before that session, the owner and facilitator, who serves as the neutral process leader, should prepare a study brief. This short document defines the project need, study objectives, boundaries, known constraints, required performance, and decisions open to change. It should also identify fixed commitments, including permits, funding conditions, stakeholder agreements, and procurement actions. Clear boundaries keep the team focused on feasible opportunities.

Build one reliable information package

The information package should give every participant the same current basis for analysis. At minimum, it should include the owner’s project requirements; design basis, meaning the criteria and assumptions that guide the design; current narratives, drawings, and calculations; applicable codes and approvals; cost estimate and assumptions; milestone schedule; procurement status; major risks; sustainability and resilience objectives; and available operating and maintenance data. Each document should show its date and status so the team can distinguish approved requirements from working assumptions.

Cost information should be organized by major project elements, not supplied only as a total. A cost model, a structured breakdown showing where resources are concentrated, helps identify functions with the greatest potential for improvement. The milestone schedule should show key design, approval, permitting, procurement, and construction dates that may limit implementation. A risk register, which records identified uncertainties and planned responses, helps the team test whether an alternative creates or reduces exposure. Consistent with this approach, FHWA’s VE Job Plan places information gathering before function analysis. [2]

Select participants for knowledge and decisions

The VE team combines the technical and operational knowledge needed to examine a project from several viewpoints. Depending on the scope, participants may include the owner, designer, estimator, scheduler, construction specialist, operator, maintainer, user representative, permitting specialist, and subject-matter experts, people with specialized knowledge relevant to the study. Select participants for their knowledge, not title alone. It sis generally recommended that five to eight participants with backgrounds suited to the project’s scope and complexity work well. [3]

The designer should explain the design basis and constraints, while independent participants test assumptions without treating the workshop as a critique of the design team. The owner should also name an executive sponsor, meaning the senior representative who supports the study and resolves policy issues, and a decision maker authorized to receive and act on the recommendations.

Prepare participants to work, not merely attend

Several days before the workshop, distribute the study brief, information package, agenda, participant roles, and questions requiring attention. Ask participants to review the material and identify missing information or conflicts before the first session. At the kickoff, confirm terminology, assumptions, constraints, and evaluation criteria. Evaluation criteria are the agreed measures used to compare alternatives, such as function, safety, reliability, cost, schedule, maintainability, environmental impact, and stakeholder acceptance.

The owner should also establish who will validate calculations, price alternatives, review code or permit effects, decide on recommendations, and track implementation. A technically sound proposal creates no value until decision makers act on it. The readiness plan should therefore include review dates, accountable parties, and the evidence required for approval.

Before authorizing the workshop, the owners are recommended to ask:

(1) Are the objectives and boundaries clear?

(2) Is the information current and detailed enough for function, cost, schedule, and life-cycle analysis?

(3) Are technical knowledge, operational experience, stakeholder awareness, and decision authority represented?

(4) Are commitments distinguished from open decisions?

(5) Is there a defined process for validating, deciding, and implementing recommendations?

References

[1] SAVE International. About the Value Methodology.

[2] Federal Highway Administration. The Value Engineering Process and Job Plan.

[3] Federal Highway Administration. Value Engineering Frequently Asked Questions.

Adroit to Present a CMAA Webinar on February 4, 2021

Please join Adroit’s Amin Terouhid, Ph.D., PMP for the following CMAA webinar:


Topic: The Value Engineering (VE) Process and Its Uses in Various Project Phases

Abstract: This webinar will describe the value methodology, explain how this methodology can be used in various development phases of a construction project, and identify the benefits of value engineering and value analysis studies.


Webinar Date: February 4, 2021 @ 2-3 pm EDT

Sponsored by: Construction Management Association of America (CMAA)

Find out more at:

https://www.cmaanet.org/course/value-engineering-ve-process-and-its-uses-various-project-phases


Register now!